json_encode indent parameter

2 years ago by Timon de Groot — view source

unread

It's not possible to tell json_encode what indentation level should be
used when using
the JSON_PRETTY_PRINT option (2, 4, 8, etc). When generating JSON files
which can be
used/read/edited by users, indentation starts to become a relevant topic.

JavaScript has a function called JSON.stringify wich accepts the
optional 'space' parameter
- See
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/JSON/stringify
Python has a function called json.dump which accepts the optional
'indent' parameter
(which also controls pretty printing)
- See https://docs.python.org/3/library/json.html#basic-usage

I would like to create an RFC draft to implement an 'indent' parameter.
Before I start a draft, I need to know if this is a good idea, so I
start with a few questions.

What do you think of adding an 'indent' parameter?
How would that parameter work when the JSON_PRETTY_PRINT option is
not passed?
What do you think of adding json_encode options instead, like
JSON_PRETTY_PRINT_INDENT_2 and JSON_PRETTY_PRINT_INDENT_4?

Looking forward to you replies and feedback!

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

2 years ago by David Gebler — view source

unread

It's not possible to tell json_encode what indentation level should be
used when using
the JSON_PRETTY_PRINT option (2, 4, 8, etc). When generating JSON files
which can be
used/read/edited by users, indentation starts to become a relevant topic.

JavaScript has a function called JSON.stringify wich accepts the
optional 'space' parameter

See

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/JSON/stringify

Python has a function called json.dump which accepts the optional
'indent' parameter
(which also controls pretty printing)

See https://docs.python.org/3/library/json.html#basic-usage

I would like to create an RFC draft to implement an 'indent' parameter.
Before I start a draft, I need to know if this is a good idea, so I
start with a few questions.

What do you think of adding an 'indent' parameter?

I'm not at all opposed in principle. As you've pointed out, there is both a
use case and precedent in other common languages.

How would that parameter work when the JSON_PRETTY_PRINT option is

not passed?

Give it a default value equivalent to whatever JSON_PRETTY_PRINT spits out
at the moment and silently ignore it if not formatting?

What do you think of adding json_encode options instead, like

   JSON_PRETTY_PRINT_INDENT_2 and JSON_PRETTY_PRINT_INDENT_4?

Personally I'd avoid more magic constants. The argument in favour of this
approach I suppose would be a) there are in practice a very small number of
common values for indentation which tend to be used, 2 and 4 being the most
common and b) there is already a third, optional depth parameter which
would remain before any fourth spacing parameter.

I would say though (a) is true enough but doesn't necessarily cover all use
cases, adds more magic constants and doesn't provide equivalence to the
JSON libraries of other common languages which permit for custom values,
while (b) is less of an issue with PHP 8's named parameters.

So if you do go ahead and make an RFC for this, I think my preference would
be as a new parameter on json_encode accepting a positive integer.

Looking forward to you replies and feedback!

--

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

--

To unsubscribe, visit: https://www.php.net/unsub.php

2 years ago by Jordi Boggiano — view source

unread

I would say though (a) is true enough but doesn't necessarily cover
all use
cases, adds more magic constants and doesn't provide equivalence to the
JSON libraries of other common languages which permit for custom values,
while (b) is less of an issue with PHP 8's named parameters.

So if you do go ahead and make an RFC for this, I think my preference would
be as a new parameter on json_encode accepting a positive integer.

I agree, but I'd make it accept a string|int much like JSON.stringify
does, because that way you let people pass in tabs too, or "🚀" if
that's how you want your JSON indented..

Best,
Jordi

--
Jordi Boggiano
@seldaek - https://seld.be

2 years ago by Timon de Groot — view source

unread

I agree, but I'd make it accept a string|int much like JSON.stringify
does, because that way you let people pass in tabs too, or "🚀" if
that's how you want your JSON indented..

I like the idea of accepting string|int.

Accepting string|int means a zval needs to be used, with the possibility
to pass any type of variable (please correct me if I'm wrong here).
Should the function throw an error when it receives anything other than
a string|int?

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

2 years ago by G. P. B. — view source

unread

I agree, but I'd make it accept a string|int much like JSON.stringify
does, because that way you let people pass in tabs too, or "🚀" if
that's how you want your JSON indented..

I like the idea of accepting string|int.

Accepting string|int means a zval needs to be used, with the possibility
to pass any type of variable (please correct me if I'm wrong here).
Should the function throw an error when it receives anything other than
a string|int?

That's incorrect, as of PHP 8.0 Fast ZPP has a way to deal with the most
common union types, including int|string.

Best regards,

George P. Banyard

2 years ago by Timon de Groot — view source

unread

That's incorrect, as of PHP 8.0 Fast ZPP has a way to deal with the most
common union types, including int|string.

Best regards,

George P. Banyard

I found that STR_OR_LONG works fine, thanks for acknowledging!

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

2 years ago by Ayesh Karunaratne — view source

unread

Hi Timon,
Thank you for this RFC. I think the string|int $indent approach is great 🚀!

Reading the PR, it looks like $indent=0 is essentially turning off
pretty-print, which I think is intuitive.

Do you plan to add any sort of validation on negative integers?
Perhaps throw a \ValueError exception on $indent < 0?

Thank you.
Ayesh.

That's incorrect, as of PHP 8.0 Fast ZPP has a way to deal with the most
common union types, including int|string.

Best regards,

George P. Banyard

I found that STR_OR_LONG works fine, thanks for acknowledging!

--

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

--

To unsubscribe, visit: https://www.php.net/unsub.php

2 years ago by Timon de Groot — view source

unread

Hi Timon,
Thank you for this RFC. I think the string|int $indent approach is great 🚀!

Reading the PR, it looks like $indent=0 is essentially turning off
pretty-print, which I think is intuitive.
Basically, yes. With $indent=0, no indentation will take place but new
lines will still be added.
Do you plan to add any sort of validation on negative integers?
Perhaps throw a \ValueError exception on $indent < 0?

Good question. Personally I'd prefer clamping $indent to 0 when it
reaches below 0. But I'd like
to hear about what other particpants think about such behavior.

Thank you for your feedback :).

Kind regards,

Timon de Groot

2 years ago by Jordi Boggiano — view source

unread

Hi Timon,
Thank you for this RFC. I think the string|int $indent approach is
great 🚀!

Reading the PR, it looks like $indent=0 is essentially turning off
pretty-print, which I think is intuitive.
Basically, yes. With $indent=0, no indentation will take place but
new lines will still be added.
Do you plan to add any sort of validation on negative integers?
Perhaps throw a \ValueError exception on $indent < 0?

Good question. Personally I'd prefer clamping $indent to 0 when it
reaches below 0. But I'd like
to hear about what other particpants think about such behavior.

IMO the JS spec is quite reasonable there, and I would say copying it
1:1 would be fine:

If this is a Number, it indicates the number of space characters to
use as white space; this number is capped at 10 (if it is greater, the
value is just 10). Values less than 1 indicate that no space should be used.

If this is a String, the string (or the first 10 characters of the
string, if it's longer than that) is used as white space. If this
parameter is not provided (or is null), no white space is used.

Best,
Jordi

--
Jordi Boggiano
@seldaek - https://seld.be

2 years ago by Timon de Groot — view source

unread

So if you do go ahead and make an RFC for this, I think my preference
would be as a new parameter on json_encode accepting a positive integer.

Thank your for your input, I'll start working on an RFC to introduce a
new parameter for json_encode.

2 years ago by Guilliam Xavier — view source

unread

Hello,

I have seen a similar discussion for var_export(), and the answer was
basically "use a regex". E.g.:

$json = preg_replace_callback(
    '/^(?: {4})+/m',
    fn ($m) => str_repeat($indent, strlen($m[0]) / 4),
    json_encode($data, JSON_PRETTY_PRINT)
);

That said, I wouldn't mind a new indent parameter (but note that allowing
an arbitrary string [not limited to whitespace] might result in invalid
JSON).

Regards,

--
Guilliam Xavier