Brachning PHP5_0 from HEAD

21 years ago by Andrey Hristov — view source

unread

Hi,
so PHP5 (currenlty HEAD) is feature freezed and therefore new code goes nowhere,
only bugfixes go to php-src module since PHP_4_3 is also feature freezed. Is it ok, to
branch PHP5_0 from HEAD so new developments to go to HEAD and bugfixes will go to
PHP5_0 and HEAD. I know that this way we will have 3 branches but hopefully
there will be nothing after 4.3.5 (which is iin RC phase now).
So which is better? To have the branch made in the next week or when 4.3.5 is
released? Or not branching after 5.0.0 is released which nobody knows when it will be done :)

Andrey

21 years ago by Edin Kadribasic — view source

unread

I think its way too early for that. PHP_5_0 branch should IMHO be created
after php-5.0.0 has been released at the earliest.

Edin

----- Original Message -----
From: "Andrey Hristov" php@hristov.com
To: internals@lists.php.net
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2004 1:18 PM
Subject: [PHP-DEV] Brachning PHP5_0 from HEAD

Hi,
so PHP5 (currenlty HEAD) is feature freezed and therefore new code goes
nowhere,
only bugfixes go to php-src module since PHP_4_3 is also feature freezed. Is
it ok, to
branch PHP5_0 from HEAD so new developments to go to HEAD and bugfixes will
go to
PHP5_0 and HEAD. I know that this way we will have 3 branches but hopefully
there will be nothing after 4.3.5 (which is iin RC phase now).
So which is better? To have the branch made in the next week or when 4.3.5
is
released? Or not branching after 5.0.0 is released which nobody knows when
it will be done :)

Andrey

21 years ago by Andi Gutmans — view source

unread

At 01:18 PM 1/14/2004 +0100, Andrey Hristov wrote:

Hi,
so PHP5 (currenlty HEAD) is feature freezed and therefore new code goes
nowhere,
only bugfixes go to php-src module since PHP_4_3 is also feature freezed.
Is it ok, to
branch PHP5_0 from HEAD so new developments to go to HEAD and bugfixes
will go to
PHP5_0 and HEAD. I know that this way we will have 3 branches but hopefully
there will be nothing after 4.3.5 (which is iin RC phase now).
So which is better? To have the branch made in the next week or when 4.3.5 is
released? Or not branching after 5.0.0 is released which nobody knows when
it will be done :)

I prefer waiting for RC1 to start a new-features branch. At least we then
know that we're on the right track. There are still some minor changes
going on (besides bug fixes) in tidy and SimpleXML.
What change do you want to make. If it's minor I think we can make an
exception.

Andi

21 years ago by Andrei Zmievski — view source

unread

I prefer waiting for RC1 to start a new-features branch. At least we then
know that we're on the right track. There are still some minor changes
going on (besides bug fixes) in tidy and SimpleXML.
What change do you want to make. If it's minor I think we can make an
exception.

I'd rather not have new-features branch at all. Let's keep the new
development on HEAD.

Andrei

21 years ago by Rasmus Lerdorf — view source

unread

I prefer waiting for RC1 to start a new-features branch. At least we then
know that we're on the right track. There are still some minor changes
going on (besides bug fixes) in tidy and SimpleXML.
What change do you want to make. If it's minor I think we can make an
exception.

I'd rather not have new-features branch at all. Let's keep the new
development on HEAD.

Right, I think we are all in agreement on that. Branch for releases,
develop on HEAD.

-Rasmus

21 years ago by Andi Gutmans — view source

unread

At 01:30 PM 1/14/2004 +0100, Edin Kadribasic wrote:

I think its way too early for that. PHP_5_0 branch should IMHO be created
after php-5.0.0 has been released at the earliest.

Even better, but RC1 is a bare minimum IMO.

Andi