Random Monday thought.

I think the point was that if somebody wants to extend one another class,
maybe one of the SPL classes for example, they can't also extend the base
class with getter/setter support so it's an incomplete solution that will
frustrate many users.

On Mon, Jun 3, 2013 at 2:20 PM, Richard Quadling rquadling@gmail.comwrote:

On Mon, Jun 3, 2013 at 6:49 PM, Richard Quadling <rquadling@gmail.com
wrote:

Hi.

Recently the setters/getters rfc was declined.

Other than the vote, was there any technical reasons?

I've been sitting here and had a thought.

Currently, if I use ...

<?php
class some_base_class {}
?>

I can, sort of, think of this as ...

<?php
class some_base_class extends \stdClass {}
?>

in as much as \stdClass has no constants, properties or methods. In
fact,
no behaviour at all.

Now, could it be possible that I could have another PHP maintained base
class or interface that DID support setters/getters?

So, I would have to make the decision at develop time ...

<?php
class some_base_class extends \stdClassThatHasSetterGetterSupport {}
?>

sort of thing.

So, for classes NOT extending \stdClassThatHasSetterGetterSupport, the
variable/property handling to be used is the original style.

But for those base classes that do extend from
\stdClassThatHasSetterGetterSupport, then these would have property
support.

Is this even possible/feasible?

Whilst the vote went against the initial rfc, I'm happy to accept that
(though I wish it had passed as I like the black boxing and the
semantic
cleanliness it would provide - IMHO).

To me, if the internals operated as ...

<?php
class \stdClassThatHasSetterGetterSupport extends \stdClass {}
?>

add if that was enough to enable setters/getters, then COULD this be a
way
forward for PHP supporting new functionality without breaking base
functionality?

In essence, turning PHP's internals into a sort of OOP framework.

Regards,

Richard.

PHP does not support multiple inheritance. So no, this doesn't solve
really the issue.

Nikita

I'm not talking about multiple inheritance, but of extension.

A new internal PHP base class which internally extends from stdClass, but
is a class that provides additional functionality, specifically
setter/getter logic.

So, from userland, I can not extend and get the current stdClass, or I can
choose \stdClassThatHasSetterGetterSupport and get that.

And if I so wish, I can implement
SomeOtherPHPSuppliedIterfaceLikeIteratorOrWhatever.

Richard.

Ah. DOH!

Would having an interface that swapped the default property accessor logic
be any better?

So, I could say ...

<?php
class myBase implements \PHPMaintainedSetterGetterLogic {}
?>

Hmmm...

I know it is still not perfect.

Shame.

I really would have liked setter/getter.

--
Richard Quadling
Twitter : @RQuadling
EE : http://e-e.com/M_248814.html
Zend : http://bit.ly/9O8vFY