Hi folks,
I just opened a vote for the curl-wrappers removal in 5.5. Since we are in
a tight schedule, the vote duration will only be a week and will end April
24th.
You can vote there : https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl-wrappers-removal-rfc#vote
Regards,
Pierrick
--001a11c37cdc78c2e304da95cfde
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1Hi folks,
I just opened a vote for the curl-wrappers removal in 5.5. Since we are in
a tight schedule, the vote duration will only be a week and will end April
24th.You can vote there : https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl-wrappers-removal-rfc#vote
As a friendly reminder. I tag beta4 on Wednesday around 10:00 UTC. Is this
getting into before or not?
David
Hi,
The vote is supposed to end on April 24th, but if there is no objection, I
will end it tomorrow and merge it if there is no change in the vote results.
Pierrick
--001a11c37cdc78c2e304da95cfde
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1Hi folks,
I just opened a vote for the curl-wrappers removal in 5.5. Since we are
in
a tight schedule, the vote duration will only be a week and will end
April
24th.You can vote there :
https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl-wrappers-removal-rfc#voteAs a friendly reminder. I tag beta4 on Wednesday around 10:00 UTC. Is this
getting into before or not?David
David, All,
I just committed the patch to remove curl-wrappers from PHP5.5. It 's one
day before schedule but we need to make sure the merge was done before the
new beta release.
Pierrick
Hi,
The vote is supposed to end on April 24th, but if there is no objection, I
will end it tomorrow and merge it if there is no change in the vote results.Pierrick
--001a11c37cdc78c2e304da95cfde
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1Hi folks,
I just opened a vote for the curl-wrappers removal in 5.5. Since we are
in
a tight schedule, the vote duration will only be a week and will end
April
24th.You can vote there :
https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl-wrappers-removal-rfc#voteAs a friendly reminder. I tag beta4 on Wednesday around 10:00 UTC. Is this
getting into before or not?David
Hi Pierrick,
Why the big rush? There have been three more votes against removing it in
PHP 5.5 since your last email yesterday so I don't think closing the vote
early is warranted, but I'm in general confused about the rush to do this
in PHP 5.5 anyway.
In principle I'm in favour of moving it to PECL until it's stable, but
since it's part of the core already and not causing active harm I really
don't see why that can't wait until PHP.next, and we use the interim to
warn/educate users.
I think the decision to remove a feature so late in the release process
should err heavily on the side of caution, and this process has been quite
the opposite. (Is a 6-line RFC a record? ;)
Regards,
Arpad
On Tue, Apr 23, 2013 at 10:05 PM, Pierrick Charron pierrick@adoy.netwrote:
David, All,
I just committed the patch to remove curl-wrappers from PHP5.5. It 's one
day before schedule but we need to make sure the merge was done before the
new beta release.Pierrick
Hi,
The vote is supposed to end on April 24th, but if there is no objection,
I
will end it tomorrow and merge it if there is no change in the vote
results.Pierrick
--001a11c37cdc78c2e304da95cfde
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1Hi folks,
I just opened a vote for the curl-wrappers removal in 5.5. Since we
are
in
a tight schedule, the vote duration will only be a week and will end
April
24th.You can vote there :
https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl-wrappers-removal-rfc#voteAs a friendly reminder. I tag beta4 on Wednesday around 10:00 UTC. Is
this
getting into before or not?David
Hi
2013/4/24 Arpad Ray arraypad@gmail.com:
Hi Pierrick,
Why the big rush? There have been three more votes against removing it in
PHP 5.5 since your last email yesterday so I don't think closing the vote
early is warranted, but I'm in general confused about the rush to do this
in PHP 5.5 anyway.
We still have 75% vs 25% on that vote if you account for those new
votes, doesn't make much of a difference (like on the ZO+ vote). That
it is a rush was favored by the RMs to get it removed prior RC stage
to follow our release schedule.
In principle I'm in favour of moving it to PECL until it's stable, but
since it's part of the core already and not causing active harm I really
don't see why that can't wait until PHP.next, and we use the interim to
warn/educate users.
I in all honestly doubt anyone is gonna work actively on that when its
moved to PECL, same as some of the extensions we in early versions
moved to PECL to have releases there but never had any, but it would
be nice indeed if someone did.
No matter how much we advertise it in our manual, or even front page
news, its limited in terms of far it will reach, and the only action
to take against removing such "harm" as a buggy feature can cause is
far better off to be removed as nobody will see our big red box saying
"Don't enable this in production". I personally would consider the use
of enabling the cURL wrapper(s) the same as enabling safe_mode in 5.3,
its things you "simply do not do" but our userbase does it anyway
since we grant them the ability to do so and the only way to stop that
is to make a stand and remove it if its not fixed. Now I do realize
that removing something is a temporary fix, but in this case its an
experimental feature.
I think the decision to remove a feature so late in the release process
should err heavily on the side of caution, and this process has been quite
the opposite. (Is a 6-line RFC a record? ;)
What more do you want than a 6 liner (its actually 7 including the
patch link) RFC, it goes straight to the point.
--
regards,
Kalle Sommer Nielsen
kalle@php.net