[VOTE] Object Initializer

Hey Michal,

Overall, I like the idea of simplifying constructors. I downvoted the RFC
because:

• I don't like/want co-existence of ctor and initializer
• __set interactions seem to also be a lot of non-trivial added
  complexity.

If this was a short-hand for a constructor replacement (exposed in the same
way downstream and in reflection) I'd totally be for it, but as it is it
blurs the entire class definition by a lot, making things very difficult to
anything reflection-ish based.

On Mon, Oct 7, 2019, 13:18 Michał Brzuchalski michal@brzuchalski.com
wrote:

Hi all,

A follow-up note.
There is no implementation of a patch yet.

BR,
Michał Brzuchalski

pon., 7 paź 2019 o 13:00 Michał Brzuchalski michal@brzuchalski.com
napisał(a):

Hi all,

the discussion period was long and discussion I think quite
comprehensive.

The RFC is at https://wiki.php.net/rfc/object-initializer and is up for
voting now.
The voting will take 2 weeks from 11:00 UTC 7th till 11:00 UTC 21st of
October 2019.

BR,
Michał Brzuchalski

--
regards / pozdrawiam,

Michał Brzuchalski
about.me/brzuchal
brzuchalski.com

Hi Michał

I can't help but wonder: why did you start the vote to begin with? It seemed to me that, based on the discussion feedback, it would never pass in its current form.

Kind regards
Brent

Hi all,

I've closed the vote. Object Initializer RFC failed with 26 votes against
and only 3 in favour.
The second vote has a meaning only for future revive of this feature.
The majority decided that the preferred assign token should be eq "=".

Thanks to all for taking a vote.

Cheers,
Michał Brzuchalski

pon., 7 paź 2019 o 13:00 Michał Brzuchalski michal@brzuchalski.com
napisał(a):

Hi all,

the discussion period was long and discussion I think quite comprehensive.

The RFC is at https://wiki.php.net/rfc/object-initializer and is up for
voting now.
The voting will take 2 weeks from 11:00 UTC 7th till 11:00 UTC 21st of
October 2019.

BR,
Michał Brzuchalski