Unset static properties View as Markdown

Hi internals,

I came across this when playing with static properties:

class A {
    public static int $x;
}

// This throws, as expected:
// Error: Typed static property A::$x must not be accessed before

initialization
echo A::$x;

// Once we initialize the property:
A::$x = 1;
echo A::$x; // 1

// There is no way to revert the property back to uninitialized state:
// Error: Attempt to unset static property A::$x
unset(A::$x);

Is this expected behaviour? I don't currently have a use case for this, but
am wondering whether it is consistent to disallow un-initializing a static
property when it's allowed to be uninitialized in the first place.

Cheers,
Ben

On Wed, Apr 10, 2019 at 2:20 PM Benjamin Morel benjamin.morel@gmail.com
wrote:

Hi internals,

I came across this when playing with static properties:

class A {
    public static int $x;
}

// This throws, as expected:
// Error: Typed static property A::$x must not be accessed before

initialization
echo A::$x;

// Once we initialize the property:
A::$x = 1;
echo A::$x; // 1

// There is no way to revert the property back to uninitialized state:
// Error: Attempt to unset static property A::$x
unset(A::$x);

Is this expected behaviour? I don't currently have a use case for this, but
am wondering whether it is consistent to disallow un-initializing a static
property when it's allowed to be uninitialized in the first place.

We could add support for this, but as the general consensus is that we'd
much rather remove support for unsetting declared object properties (if we
could cover the lazy loading use case in a different way), I don't think it
makes sense to allow this.

Nikita

We could add support for this, but as the general consensus is that we'd
much rather remove support for unsetting declared object properties (if we
could cover the lazy loading use case in a different way), I don't think it
makes sense to allow this.

Ok, thanks. Just wanted to double check.

Note that I'm actually liking the ability to unset declared properties for
2 reasons:

• lazy loading, as you mentioned
• ability to differentiate between unloaded properties, and properties
  loaded as null from the database (useful in data mappers)

Ben