# SNMP value retrieval

- Thread: https://externals.io/message/2083
- Original archive: https://news-web.php.net/php.internals/2083
- Started by jhml@gmx.net on 2003-05-29T18:31:23+00:00
- Messages: 2
- Reply by email to internals@lists.php.net
- More for agents: search with https://externals.io/search.md?q={query} · RFCs at https://externals.io/rfc.md · JSON API at https://externals.io/api · documentation at https://externals.io/llms.txt

---

## #2083 — jhml@gmx.net — 2003-05-29T18:31:23+00:00

URL: https://externals.io/message/2083#2083

>Jonny, it your personal email address is bouncing.
>That you know (maybe even the mailinglist email bounces for you).
Sorry for that. It seems like 1409.org is permanently gone. I've now switched 
to an account I have to pay for just to be on the safe side in the future. I 
hope this will also prevent most of the spam I received as they use 
SpamAssassin...

> > […]
>Do these names to be so long?? I was thinking we cane drop the
>'VALUEMETHOD' or 'METHOD' part. Would that be OK and which do
>you prefer??
To be honest I was never happy with these names. "valuemethod" sounds clumsy 
to me, but English is not my mother tongue. I'm also not happy with 
"snmp_setvaluemethod" as a function name. Maybe we could call the function 
"snmp_setvalueretrieval" and the constants SNMP_VALUE_*? I'm really not 
insisting on names, I only want the functionality, so every comment is 
welcome!

> > […]
>I believe the ASN_ prefix should be SNMP_ and changed as such.
>That they are internally ASN_ does not matter.
Ok, I'll change these constants to SNMP_*.

>ANother thing I would like to ask is whether the group wants to support
>also all kinds of types of SNMP that are not standardized and somehow
>added to NET-SNMP as an expiriment.
>I believe it is better to drop those, what do you think??
I don't need them. If nobody gives me some reason to keep them, I'll drop 
them.

I'll wait for another week for some comments as I have a strange feeling that 
absolutely nobody else has yet commented on the patch. If no further comments 
are posted, I'll create a new patch. Would be a dream if gets into 4.3.3...

Cheers, Jonny

---

## #2086 — Harrie Hazewinkel — 2003-05-29T21:46:05+00:00

URL: https://externals.io/message/2083#2086 · In reply to: #2083

> > […]
> Sorry for that. It seems like 1409.org is permanently gone. I've now 
> switched
> to an account I have to pay for just to be on the safe side in the 
> future. I
> hope this will also prevent most of the spam I received as they use
> SpamAssassin...

I had hazewinkel.net also and maybe within the spam I did
not receive or see the invoice of the domain.

> > […]
> To be honest I was never happy with these names. "valuemethod" sounds 
> clumsy
> to me, but English is not my mother tongue. I'm also not happy with
> "snmp_setvaluemethod" as a function name. Maybe we could call the 
> function
> "snmp_setvalueretrieval" and the constants SNMP_VALUE_*? I'm really not
> insisting on names, I only want the functionality, so every comment is
> welcome!

The names are not that important, but long ones require a lot
of typing from programmers and shorter ones avoid such a change.
I would 'VALUEMETHOD' drop completely.


> > […]
> Ok, I'll change these constants to SNMP_*.

OK.
> > […]
> I don't need them. If nobody gives me some reason to keep them, I'll 
> drop
> them.

I would say only standard bits. The expirimental parts
as as said, expirimental and many agents do not have them
either.

> I'll wait for another week for some comments as I have a strange 
> feeling that
> absolutely nobody else has yet commented on the patch. If no further 
> comments
> are posted, I'll create a new patch. Would be a dream if gets into 
> 4.3.3...

Not sure, but why not.

Harrie
