Newsgroups: php.internals Path: news.php.net Xref: news.php.net php.internals:128803 X-Original-To: internals@lists.php.net Delivered-To: internals@lists.php.net Received: from php-smtp4.php.net (php-smtp4.php.net [45.112.84.5]) by lists.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 3781F1A00BC for ; Thu, 9 Oct 2025 20:39:58 +0000 (UTC) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=php.net; s=mail; t=1760042402; bh=jrKKsqhmvSROXViihNZvF1NZ/wkwkH0a16T/67wLXyg=; h=Date:Subject:To:References:From:In-Reply-To:From; b=UmSeOwCq11hPL3NYUrZnne8d6OOqTNq7HPoXhgReBtKQVjpVMFek44sM52vYaFrsN FTKrix1/P5NLfG6xPhHogy2ZtBQudlJRsF/PUA4F8s/5DWw2dejDMWRzFOD4M4kZwU qg1BmSwmzZBa393RTqX0/EvdTsLOgJ1+5Bg+bk9qX870lFqWEDJFIH0GHdWOUCehrl tUTa5kPsoHTGpheneqgpNeBJHmX6RP6Q6GceJ4CsgGk4cDnbMRZodFqWpkuxiH2hfZ Jo8v0O8MBk+ojvZI84qO0lQpNYbwUXWWkBWJXU2+u8EB96g117mRShf1yG0bDVb1xV YW49UKYBFhjGw== Received: from php-smtp4.php.net (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by php-smtp4.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2414D18054A for ; Thu, 9 Oct 2025 20:40:02 +0000 (UTC) X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 4.0.1 (2024-03-25) on php-smtp4.php.net X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=0.2 required=5.0 tests=BAYES_50,DKIM_SIGNED, DKIM_VALID,DKIM_VALID_AU,DKIM_VALID_EF,DMARC_PASS, FREEMAIL_ENVFROM_END_DIGIT,FREEMAIL_FROM,RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3,RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL,SPF_HELO_NONE,SPF_PASS autolearn=no autolearn_force=no version=4.0.1 X-Spam-Virus: No X-Envelope-From: Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.15.18]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange ECDHE (prime256v1) server-signature RSA-PSS (2048 bits) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by php-smtp4.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTPS for ; Thu, 9 Oct 2025 20:40:01 +0000 (UTC) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1760042391; x=1760647191; i=cmbecker69@gmx.de; bh=QoGN8xqzA51zFsNZ1nzoSIssyWqHDR6Qp276j/FV8Rc=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To: References:From:In-Reply-To:Content-Type: Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc:content-transfer-encoding: content-type:date:from:message-id:mime-version:reply-to:subject: to; b=IrcBNGIW8CaETrtt/nu4jvHS7shsAmBpsSvs94l7wCqPP4QR1GBJ8VnSu3xjfvuy USSe/r59pcJFILKH+uTHwad06vzC5tQLINCPOrRE7+kxr8mik2SXMKRGrt2VbxJcK GW9PSQ47BVpq2P9MuYtYEz95pjPnu+Ox84YxyIPXWrvHITS1azi2AYy/rl6x0mJB4 D+JecFwY+SlXT/p0z/2H2Fl6R/yAGfiX9pk/EWAIWkRahgKT2YIlcdATxDPqVNRXL ju+3YxUkVEm32oDf56U9Qq3h1UNK907Eq1ZF5YqS3L42GPmtZ2ZiSPtYG+j054iCP cfJbMVbQFWmFsw1Ipw== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from [192.168.2.198] ([79.220.75.163]) by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx004 [212.227.17.190]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MPokD-1uudV62W7n-00HnDg; Thu, 09 Oct 2025 22:39:51 +0200 Message-ID: Date: Thu, 9 Oct 2025 22:39:52 +0200 Precedence: list list-help: list-post: List-Id: x-ms-reactions: disallow MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird Subject: Re: [PHP-DEV] [RFC] [Discussion] Deprecate PEAR and recommend Composer Content-Language: de-DE To: james@asgrim.com, PHP Internals List References: In-Reply-To: Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:CTdj/98oG0LfN8JZwWYQqIa/srcSvwDfLKf+tS685rL8FWfgANH WhTB7Y9T74/MRx/dz4m4DsCcu0nX2AU7sYbcg/qdiYvdzK296X12kzzVU6FN+j2Ekkyt59o mcu8L5Fv2lstsfOKkn51WFggpuo+PvsJUlDmq51hl8i+uwgu08tqQ0p/sYSZ9nBDPVaSrML Fng/t/lbyarVNYHZg9pWA== UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:/25/CASmKcI=;4TnGZEaXEYMQ5Ki7ZSNOP0695y5 V9mMMIbafDVKgZNDigRJ1gyFK5FBvFEkU2LEjo38jbK0tiBZvAHKYeRRHvwaqCghIhthNtI8P uP8DyXs7tLZgv40lNimk8JnO145347oCwYCau+v1Kch7kYXPNWKk1vWNc8dAwaHi5dXUrzdfK J3EaZvSyQcJ8Z1x751QM3Ne+RC9uJwo6OwNUJ0RKGBG+EARQ1gyITsYrPHNFboj94zCFl6D9H MGenZie8aJUdXcLVH7P1YW/qtCu8jRF0Tuzc3kNzzEWrx2MRGKW9qmQUSCOh8Hw+f0cQky0tl zRmnhwajJjk/xRFrCtG5yNK6J7lIe7BmLo9e7woqEMO8OVcAIUbV2nVSHgUHGp01kpAnpnidm 8JN4ihX6zF61EtwDJcPAlWnWZG5gNd+JnkenFHBZmHLrW4KZpM644LVeAPZskTDd+Ta4Oa0rO XdoR1unrR2BHK7tPrGi6DXFvSPskrXpD5Ax8v3NHI+/LqmArCJN6PjGAyvA2kUQ3VoSHsC/U3 0dDVHMGjCFNkqgX1vENGSk331+oZemEPXkcMyDVuU40rhVUt4QVwCPjlT2OdAa2fhjBLK9Azy Aj3yYG3ON6fGZIE4ORVEL5rckCPsVwYoC9SG6lMAgW0QLnO3XLAyOQdixEisodHVRdkdMDx6T ZyNdWokrMe3V1OCf9N3nq9EvFiSm5ydWmPOslt9DWLAvfWiNkSt6ywbKsix2Xo9foH8+Axd8s WjKK6bnqZjPxWsFTHudrlz+I1Iqh+3HHYNBOlzLuEWyfVgcJ8yyWVr/nyzyojLs8QSRM+SBhN WwPF9zNRI94WecIGdKoJLVIJkmd6WFjFyTFxhqEfndn02KE7hZPSr80RndiIS/ALyKbuvr05x wfOwOjlwocHEpXSghLrKi4FNWsyt8Z99L4I/n1VKhoKWtRQl2EEX/KkXu2lXjsy6SpfRojp4S taVlGhc5J03vnOAbVhh6dKIsGHk5DBGDyARZ48tzeiwYnQMTcAsaNE7vJl7hTm/rgOH9cfr8u o5CZr0k4ozhDcsaqc7mxbBQ+lljdbXzqQwNzPiRDjTpCO4owmdcT/r2DJKWFbp/nT3IAK1Oog gsqOMrCY35PSKl/3mhfXpFlgaPdmmFfGvcPE73MtE3JIRTTDXeoZ5RETxpWm9sG2A+MfOiWcf rKdn7TA1o6F6RT3JA8eOBlk5wfB8eP1TliMphzos4xh6iY0T+qF3YstkdeWiB8UTMHrMm3JCa zAE9Lc3Pxm+Fnwly4xPxYvisTbsTpOYdc2wE5EVxkxlbCjB/rmGxlRbR295r/VaSK4zwfeKUj WRocfNEs1KoQubN4ZqW+AinlnEMYFT96fCTvN+a02J2a3qoKEKxeFj3O6IjFS54OsIswwUwQo gV6fnEN4YnmKAbyolwWmOG/WNfUKr6wbY0kF0hKOuTvdR28cwF9/4HzSUNRH1tmgeUQ+fvn/Z 5UcoqEA5VXdj3ZLgW3Tb47560M0ZNsVWvJmewwEKQReQgN2Zoi+/jJwGxaCicooCMR0n//8ZB VVEMcq61mOteN/F0jqtKRUvAdb+9+0QmvL7CZv5XD/cT++gKHYUq+HBPcuBx5uenQpG+Rw3XZ U2u34TzTgs3mdP0wih45/r+hwNU9hr5XN8J+tc2E/9a7bR10OSN/tLvSaZF8DS4XggcMmQwsu 0FjpcNVKPnafloGwhS4FBNP6p/yyVkvDMiD36fONodggeSiINQbuUVF/IP0jAASraE0HHqUOd hoY6xBFvMmc/XxTBMcxtcpKcnbLdLr8K53fZAm3RuPCiTgKyRwKiH31ZMNl/iN9wugZNkjb8g v1xJ6P3zkwvMAZZ+7josLiV+SpMAoCMLkHxlY5oGe11hD4kgM/4YA/MCM5MRmw0ozVqpO95/7 dIyc2MYmVas0ImBqdPKWJVTKZlTBharnXgcqCs4fcrMflgTgqWPB/SyDOxzV2USOInyxWB+gT uO97TpUPApalOMgaKJukUD5CeyKedsEU/YIOYFjPA2C3DFnTjmT7wjeNnXTvQrWdznwsvutDz XEwrtyYsdbEzRMfjgxyTtD0ioQQRdNhL+c+C3aPb0gIcQlrl4a3Uf4nniftU+nlcPgLNXEYPA KfIdGrKpAY1p2weCkY4No8SDYXqBCxw5adp5Id01sqKaevDON49ASKLSh51BW94kWIzPXb/zB 0XiyVhv8InCvMVpIbjcEukEy+eAVtg6toPi0BzfuMHxZTpjQHoyQn0DXzvK+bHvsQkRBfeJmU C2wxGr7SclmIB19j9fs1VRodbZ2A1kt1SmNzG6KiQHu6iLijNRJhperKCPuGo3x95ANJ8S9sv vtwqhzM1enX0nb80uHruV7hWJC3wRE8cO6nHne6VEKdSNyW+sMeGm6TE4cAoePz9yUhMge8Ly 9hiOZ8R+4K68ZSOQC3ZY8KWFXEY8mUaF+3gEHSXSbSaeclKo1N+7tuLv8DlEZVmhh77t5kafK GOg2PxPTlvJm6b/gspcdNQf9vr0iA/AAGHmh9SeDzqS64qWKIzn8XWG7X4JQ6AQWU9drxzvQs J3RQUlFcCkjJslcgguLJtbGTXQ6DAsE1JeHmO7np8GCilTbpw/s9QvoQbPJ6fHdJDIM4NL2nj QmnRcFAgVftCyKFlnC1Zr1Sszux+Hqrij2+Tx4T2zi3Dc3BOy7UqP67Q8ZyFldPAmQ6DbEcLg PiHxujEsbmvfpnRMMYmYjWdn9A0Iji8KwKOXsDRsGTR+ShVua8P2BSZJ5I1Z6TaWbiFFhGzif Okd9iHymHLmePtxD1AtgO738TxqQha8k8LfpmQBxcQLa2ovyCtEsH5lFYJSaOrK8TwxGcwzYp sIDyQuIzoNKpMR/MCnYst+PiP+d+eCzWsfwzflk85iFvqBflGxbaF0ndutUe58LyIn23nRMqa QQTgIm2xMuQrUCwq14R+xoPq4jCDfccgCUmu2qKcC3wZRvmfoCykqXQqvP9PQDbvomob+hCJz /x8FWf9EO5wsPMBP+hE6tKvdswD4PlDVHk3R4ONctPaO5irQ+AHoSiOPYdeOi9VVZpd83/Hgs KOp1D8j3X356tH3PZgYdjkbZ1h9nOlmwlFlu2G9pXEbZL4sT7uTuC7//0nfP0dvv6yg6EVeWH QGjadw6G1npjHPuSame3yEkJBsHHcwYhIstNqHWo5ePUOs9uKLO49Sh2Y/bkdje0/B6d2gOPP u+06P5t71rYgDKqe4xZhGNWBNQVerfDbJqeucOhCttKWn8r+RyQwFBUBYwdaK9bkkauwvkGPU mXG3R08iBKPK+dFGsBy86jLOmVdIg6A8uj/hEPl6mIzEKuozR/tsHnMyPqN0cwqwasE2h8+t/ xG5k0v4t6l0upE/dcBWZvp5XTMkvLeVAQU636bvMsqzCZS/nIJ9b2gl7g/dVxvgkiHBTny3kt EwL9yjcJv+48HTEDYcULu+sgfdiG8E5k/WZ9L+sR7E2W6JjnbRt6R3lWxnWXotyFy6NUEzACu mB5BLxOeHopj07DW70AwORPa4CqLJP4A/TYc/dv1J8h+voEORg1twFaNrYOaYAH8lJecxP+au 7jRnhZBHPQOFFvoXYX3f3UY8kUtQvvCkMeOtp3B/eu9Qc1Qo+X370jsQg9suZNvLcG40a4puh IORjrhWwZu0feJld10k3Ppn+iMudmHF/n6/hLN+FwaTx9r/s6zTcc1T0lg+rMwYzIlrumHduq TcrB14N7KUZZ+uLx82OeISbZORsQNfQs69tebWI0ks6pbF5FmrWq8PNuoguoM4fy4/shkATPZ zDFhxGosZHUz/JnaJYRmIVzFf31xRgsD9+GnXGGYVF5TZalq0FQDhMh8OLmhteX0U4/Pmx5nY gzOMIfZagVIRZBUv3uziNhK0oFQj0KFqHZBAw/1f8voOpBCe8XsJg+P98VmjHRM3+fvu85s3I uNorLNxAaFrVJ0e/s0u8kLJggbc9J2wr3RtjQ3RUXCsPRQpoNq4g3Gq5uFK2VIuy9a8+cHXb6 FT1GqhdVz/OHDiFQn+X++ChMLNKr6Qw60VPqTgRLn5P5ncnBN+nBFho6+nuxq8G/hrTNKWOPS K3Bisec733bMRqpWcvv4blQtMu7OdzrDGbANngVPIU1t8m+SEdbsge/HLi7aRaS904U+TKEFQ DMVquNe6gtyvt1doKxqpk2/hacVEaEM/3tErlolTQpc71syg3xz9HT7GnLXZ100DUAvyWNn9E ZannBprF1cm4iSzpHOIrg2iZflhiIthapShFWMJwkTGlhtaZX8i6Ej91kqwFjD+6sBYNxeG3B aMPcgBZ+AKitmBBdR4T7P4tooJjkU9IbOnhyKqWWNxhjygOhUX69VWY+XunfPlofS9M428YJi xmvPJN/OznG3esuofr4WV5Qc6hY+NxDsQg0oWjjIOrTcZXAfXrpkFoKLHzFeXFX9Pvj+Mu6hw m/fKrJknBjjTE8d2Nct3S1GRUZkr1wIOig6Rp3OVmSO+7Fd0M1Jja2xucowfdWtQHne59r9jD nCTdqUt3Yvx0/81zuYUsLIKUS0QeV4BRX4oj2k93C+SxjNjIIrwK0X6QP0Dk+Xas9RYMbKBp0 BO90OeFMvSSQgBXa2d1rHo0kd6EKhK/UXkKrT70oOJ3aw+hW1hfuQy+mFyUqLcFaMsuxZWXW1 0siGqYu3uPrD3HaGoFZtRuCzCGGqDfx/8MUk5RqyDIflmQbI1IfrpcmB+LH6aSxe90WIVoLC6 tmpOVBr7G4YU3EkwkvV2azJ73VtXDMDEICBg2yhkk6ri8SdroMB9XCvH0+Jpkb9MtIYjestXd qIAMCO/SgP/w6qI5ZdBv+vID0Z5etd4KjyYs1mVNHe6/MeM/oum0nn7mGh42OC8SlbNSmZx1x Uku8T9aRkoJkn69xxcuV9se4vBbYkxY2GiZ+wLi9szE715lpUe1GrV9iiB7fnvj0O9VydWOxE w+vr4aCE1Z/30p6TIc2td1XwhrR9BoSjDCIvgG74neSI= From: cmbecker69@gmx.de ("Christoph M. Becker") On 09.10.2025 at 12:28, James Titcumb wrote: > Presenting the RFC for deprecating PEAR and recommending Composer as the > recommended > PHP package installer: >=20 > https://wiki.php.net/rfc/deprecate_pear_recommend_composer >=20 > Plan to move to vote on or shortly after 24th October all being well. Apparently, this RFC has been withdrawn in the meantime. I would like to know why. :) Christoph