Newsgroups: php.internals Path: news.php.net Xref: news.php.net php.internals:128602 X-Original-To: internals@lists.php.net Delivered-To: internals@lists.php.net Received: from php-smtp4.php.net (php-smtp4.php.net [45.112.84.5]) by lists.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7E9C71A00BC for ; Mon, 1 Sep 2025 12:56:55 +0000 (UTC) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=php.net; s=mail; t=1756731325; bh=RiFe6LvMxxnsSV59SgAEJqpSuDO0Wz0V9QMijAz2O0g=; h=Date:Subject:To:References:From:In-Reply-To:From; b=ZKHJvKTnZUr+/TyHhdTk4ZJKsabTNNnTJhEx0lvlj6b5XwZR2D52Utm54NEvWsvUS RhVFWW7/SRYWJgmMkw6oQemtXFAs8igRCF55UqhhYKOk3Ht1htl+aGM55A+lT6cWNC UZrgtlY1MbJ8824z4WKnf+/PlFsIjPetP9jcXqpC8yX+KnSexSAEvD+Lx1Q/N3wJYe Hkpmtcn88ITJvPibi0Q4uIYDHhDiNyj4boycM8WPybG9q9tatzBhJOatXI6LfHb+uX R1IFwqwDPLAq65L6djJfhoiYTr3TYI/Dk0ALLQ9AHI1/HAOzp6Pkgrl8HybGljizqS G+R/wpymw7MDQ== Received: from php-smtp4.php.net (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by php-smtp4.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 67E61180084 for ; Mon, 1 Sep 2025 12:55:24 +0000 (UTC) X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 4.0.1 (2024-03-25) on php-smtp4.php.net X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=0.2 required=5.0 tests=BAYES_50,DKIM_SIGNED, DKIM_VALID,DKIM_VALID_AU,DKIM_VALID_EF,DMARC_PASS, FREEMAIL_ENVFROM_END_DIGIT,FREEMAIL_FROM,RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H5,RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL,SPF_HELO_NONE,SPF_PASS autolearn=no autolearn_force=no version=4.0.1 X-Spam-Virus: No X-Envelope-From: Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.15.19]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange ECDHE (prime256v1) server-signature RSA-PSS (2048 bits) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by php-smtp4.php.net (Postfix) with ESMTPS for ; Mon, 1 Sep 2025 12:55:13 +0000 (UTC) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1756731385; x=1757336185; i=cmbecker69@gmx.de; bh=0z0gucMgrpZkUhcKrrRrtdxy2ECrQVam5yOkOn7SnQk=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To: References:From:In-Reply-To:Content-Type: Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc:content-transfer-encoding: content-type:date:from:message-id:mime-version:reply-to:subject: to; b=e+eQ+bSlCwIfHAuVC7pRMIBqzioi+BCxBVmlKm5K5mzUKZSm4TQrZbuvQI+r13+r Bqna0RLPp009pvc9G0FppV7fucNAF1za8K4qiDuPjWBmT3lOJFetUawXz77Xk64l/ pgtjHZU1BKBoiYPudoShr4cxUSRdUHxtq7c57ShRQuYi2qIV9WHRDlCE9cM4VmRVj knaqVmoBQzNNBIlQfKQ/i+7AW/hntuMjHeFampM8f8kifh6qkmwIPyTSe7mSAImPX YXNNpdo5MWnQaL3tE2hL8lnucl1QXsz/e13Wa8eXpMma3AMdixgd8p1CDEUz7GF+U OaEdqp8eE5QV9va1mw== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from [192.168.2.198] ([79.220.75.163]) by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx004 [212.227.17.190]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MAfUo-1umVYv39s8-00DBvc; Mon, 01 Sep 2025 14:56:25 +0200 Message-ID: <71fd5192-8b94-4829-a69a-fcbe563b7d1e@gmx.de> Date: Mon, 1 Sep 2025 14:56:27 +0200 Precedence: list list-help: list-post: List-Id: x-ms-reactions: disallow MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird Subject: Re: [PHP-DEV] Reference of discussion in RFCs To: Nick , internals@lists.php.net References: <30FD734F-2ED4-4D48-823A-3E4E0F265D38@nicksdot.dev> Content-Language: de-DE In-Reply-To: <30FD734F-2ED4-4D48-823A-3E4E0F265D38@nicksdot.dev> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:L6rzurVubGCUjnWv+yT2pDswMllEhnNiqkZHXPBWJPjAMICWxXy COjymqY0QeFaXLl92njrSHfy4w6vBxIEduHi5GWOITygVHg/282I4GMMO/W63sLHnXU843u YD+Zjsw2qQqH1V0JX8wRnOmizy02eO+jGWIwd8ohPENtj0ptZ/BlFGrFO0Zaheg9n5TCEmH GZiw4nAYAnQzEv1+1rluw== UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:B2g2FRn/ApI=;l6KhY9Soav3tJREkn+oASRP7JeJ rqSt8kkWHG4q0R7wgSHWJT3CJU79Mrevacx8KJK3DX/EXlXCQNdDICoIBzcCIMe1wjF6SNbXj HSO9yPWFH5Rnl4cICZE2vqUdBtMG2UvGCWy/mSdyKaYOv0uVoNOubYWMW5Z1ElY24YrvxEs3l bw3vgKbgdjoguERCWnQiK7oAjJgY6sOLHWTL4aJYPQSv+x+DefS09i7Eok8Z7/Pt9OrnZYUVt Yj8UtO1rle8ox4O98A7Njo/+1f43jTGpo7deuTxkTK196D72Wa2n2e01ZSu6yJMI7Q8bZcXsJ KTt2mKzYJQ/fvJQ1GcQT9XCqFPnmBWLoAZNWLk0pXtg71UFtYKgr1Ec+18gfm60cHEnVlCXNB +k5JalR7pC9uC5hG9iXJnKuGbqLiL8HwvaLfLlcVf/59CnJ7jgAL6zLxOr4cCu/XjaKtwD4d2 vpuGXT+Url3RyHhzg8eyD4/RsMLIt98qFkgKW1SpHveD2GtWsh07dBsJsAJoTeZL7+KYHHnLs wMLtwgJlEBW5DCvG/FE7z+tvT4+AD42FuUaK99LcKCDL+OrHHuXNS3U8kMVOBkfTZX7Q5zTvw Snxs0yY0sZEVqUTzddnpPdWns4WCto6lA/G8Ktk61OaQJIjYJVDdTopeFyWdQ3JNIQbufzIKk eD4wbjaiUB90xZzqJ8ASvDgyXB9UNf/CnRQPFZsK/Dqsu5e5cKo5pyqmuoKAoQ6VJx5KDvZx9 ZlSPm58XiU2WGID2uZU0zjH3wtRq/Hy3YbLGOKmr54ZddJybal5IvEArEFBeAplyO6f6eQ37E AA5NyLTDDlywy3m4Heg4lE7jocSsi3lDPb3anhHVaZRB5PgSiY6s7pPlgV7AIOFbsrXg1k4/Z /bawmbQI8zujVh8Xklw9P3uwH7WLnDfkP43gIYOUuJEEhByc+CcWtWSubvSlTQ8LXvjacKtnh Daui8PIpHJHTP+igvz9Dk+pE47f3abp92Gyws43AghFBC5MqS+Qj0YkdT3itobpbiND+Bi5+j K772QLj7KIftWaT+vafqcdYirNp/SNz7t4q4Zzth5W8TVZA2tc2XH0a8qI8DrD9U86I2q9yzW ZUQumAZS3eaES2Hd8/vCoMD2OulqQJIr5MrTjYb9tx6190GpXPbUt+4v+pbWzdOXc7jdwAE2j bzVd9QWhRX6LEm2dXptrCZq9K7y7AUOanbR47RGh73qvWyEejturCqS9I7JMCJeGlS2rjKMzs VYbGhz2tiUsyM/Ihumxyjov4jNx4jxyR/jJqwqZ/08gYQ3lgyIQcCfg38BrfkpjIjRuXYyXRw 0jRlKm3aRgSL9bY54UAjPfn42A7/7quBqf4JkU6wJzD9Qtsmhd/A2grO0PVlg2EvxnXZt1Dtf x90G1nq1gO0WFTi26X+0vKftQvt006X4YjLz55SBBoRjFYpg3Y/ClgHWrccyDmdKsRckVOG4X C1ZdyBUNoDPo8RyKRder762jCdOspUgmkXV0yJMBYDTgTAYU0oUsJ2XNkHcOPLB5CLEz2ytca 6x2qTQ2cL8+mR96TJyTor24ZEISF0lpSxBmnbIXFxLZ1kM1SGdEn0ZCSJGzHh9WuOhMc6JWPK t8FRNa9KRHzA3G6tXlFHmVyNJh82zgsgTFScJayGf1QRt2RmBBBqduxCcT4ETqyf4UoesQ5oD xRm6fxFXl0FrpdlYpnLNKyN5ukAsmNJC1joCTxLaUKZELXHXvJ7Qm056QoXwdOW5bIM2/m4xr 75Sbv0tiY3OcorJFrwcqG99YWAstcJd0b0ryFTO/NBeLqBf+LoTfsBCXevOZ/Z9eTNuP41YtN ho+8fn0nyVQ0wJbNfR5UYKXtKR8Alh2qpVM6TCwEv6TNJp9SVoIcbUhIll8hgkmSTxsprgB9w Ic7EbcIU2G52qbC5MkEUxYZJwyZ5iSZQCrc6AsTlHTBF7s5YLCqUIcn1zpkBoMlN4upF2HRk4 ml2alG9x4wYITwkk5p8f5oIiNx2+fL40wmgPTmtfOpVpgHMcwuis4fKewSPbRpI5WJqAm6XVY WI5QpZDiL6+CA73BCme3WE2CKhE30dB7EqsWP1yjiQ0n/NnyQHJU2eC8MCsTEJGVV3sjP/Icp wFL1x8pfPq9+XiMqPtRL1E+5GJwSfNnFuJKk0X4pqw2uxGF4okBkWlm7kjJ15UTijNmNwtaRp LYRobbYpyxK0yQMUxn8TL2sOSnKB1pg2RHz1lc5+NKdxXtVvY2FAirVhCZpu8TZ1Mzc8xqz5x WNkZR6VsyY4yXsNF7Z06aUb5sCaRHQOx2SHziclbuuTvXwUir9Qo5SZIKGxwzbpLTNhReey1G YazWjaUDfKf/nGzmNGxWkxaZ4kXVp25hPHxhEggOCOGxBqYiqe6skio9P6sw5UicZG9ohPqXh 3yxis/FQlFf+DBP4pEen+4en+QZxUGFvh3PCepmp3gVVCM3wOpwn0hwUvzlnTQG3DyWv405Pl Y8eax/+MZ8F/nulw9V95EHm17ynk3BhEORK30EffIOrUvW8qTnOTS93UYs0/t1scwHzHZwYD+ z4pzs+uwXrELh++vPHk3qMI845/ZQX6QchyNWy09oqMJzgXdA0lz/pn3xu71X+nqlF5pmH3wi ZSlxAgz03kLFG+KSRosni7WvqCgx0/ilySwYtpvMlASfiBQxSXmvprHsBGRUFQDwbquol6rlx KNEzdiLVo+PHytz01sgHYO/2+reYY4Z9U96l2iVNPwXCV8JCbpjHyi25v2Mei9Z9EA13qTco2 OUtt+5lxN4qC+PojsIdzQRIt8c9BVoZEv9v9ivnHdvX8eCR0t2Z4eXqgsWXgcpVMZQdmTUCyT Dum9HURr//1ZARhPlq4oIGiZZDFPFW7sBp0t5TNS60Z8E2FRNYsr8MKUXhZkchZ8PLysa5bAA oWkTLh1OoNiU72yLWKPaP19peE2fitoXBclgnEe4MK3cMwJ1Cf9nAFSdXfKMa1eGef/t5stbS zD6pAf0dbx88nNLke3dQ4fqjTziZY0iY60fSW9qVBGaA0qrFbTFHrU8EXMxe0E7p3N2UUZKXc YEfdk3KGHtsjdbXKfPm9Cc7nBbalB6ahpIi7IW0BDXfRKuMycp4npVfCfvoSEK8KSSiCIBSl8 GgCMjb/t/VnNQY9u8x35sPeSBcWvgBXlXOzJQ7lAWrBEN6yXnLLhZki0BqoAsPNk059GtHvhA VirGW1vGvhi5WhyUUXQyEwC0haiZvcxWcpv/3EaJMyrVKBNgC/3gWJAlZ7xrWDxMnh3F6RHEO FJrKiW/EMWFEgGMzlydAimeu/ZF1RWvy4ZQwBipm83WqNKtqDi0Txe9yMD/lSv1Bd62x8NSUh m23N22T29CztgJLtK/u2NFVxxpH38jd7s0A6jFtbZF5JNdIBQxttxivWXEkndDJc+vKUTHTnF MDEP8Yw/+4tJs+6CRi39HnDek4P0sc2muSkkgU/S1AZARsSvLXJ7tU80x2MOkZzplhMgMyJWE mCRJlyMzUzB3m5q32r+xG6z1IkRpzpN96mDlyYzCu43f54J/AA2V95+u7XlWEV9i+JC/i7BeV vyD/GyFT7cB9OnScGYFLD4qX6zJXzHLu4oB68Tnuma1e4qNo5sBmPABsmEOaqKKptUrHEqz/E quvddFMXVY5lkIDE8QHbk/0YylJGCr7mPx78RDEPFb3WkAIAcLHvfDnNLW3nABmRSZAI/pg8U 4cbxscq0r1fxC1gEEGZK7ua/2+9YXzL5tQ0f8+DsHguvrAUsUdbA56WnHxSfpRClXrIGLiWVG vL+k++6tEScdmUgxDzmd1Vqaxs05BvAvcrM/P3gkeqf4jWQu+mrxaXUGohnWxC0NFJjwc+UGV Y9R/774AakS7wRINny+b28N+xN5evOxV7o4mdXB9ITgzJcu8qdYf5IGRW06p/iVWa+tSb6P1F 10YRqvSihmCAWmESZADHGtTRZieX/JaC67LphhmAuP6UD4KojoB25YcijY0QZClYhq99L6kgf f07yxIeA3fxaDU7PMfOcO8e4Qq1d3nT/55yI5/Ui2zlUNHHbSvuernCY3VRx3WWFKF3kikQlT rT9/PrfPlB+pyxokTCxTsbVyWc9fUVKKV5nf1QeQftAGSFZYisd0dkUXqjcB0UzNCOF4sF8xy 6sVlmailm5yFZPlfPsXyclSY+w+gjyOQd+CVSAijjga4955s2hLua4Jyn8/iUanTuGi+3xxIf 6rhHU8z45T+QeN9e0rYGpcK3SedUWbDbvWwuNit2IP/aeowYjFGHnhrEkiwzbIaOHO3CQuYfj 0uPerk4eC/F1kEPFY/n/8EVp8G3j2BO4kFNs2qR2KXpmmrRwjROh1mkLvuTrB7uaXtxOE/JXm jd4NVEpzcrTCzdjE/enhuSyZSwZFsgTVRtYi4aBvQlE7Aez4J4nkPe5W1IuMPn/LybCS1Th4f 7whSTqr1YH6SjP5j9AShnzb8qppflW7fPl2OJv4C1sQjrEpcvwbDIu9NdiFxrYP+UVPGJgb+y +qO8KuG/rq/qi44b/eysDIDOEMGaSZ49UiPsIpkd6Ohg+WS9j50BgD3e9dQehlIUSLbO1nWM3 qqS+Lgur77jkDV+9NzhEuNs4CEX6zwR0hkZxPxXTgVGu01IVFsqxi5zAq1Cx4+JWA+FI6K2GN 37X2W/l85ZbrYHBL3oZh9U/eMyCUU1sZH40EahkgNME/E4Ae7uhp8i6mx//2TaVAYYwHk7rB2 nx8n1k1MED+wWs+5iUsgNGCnsuc8yO8sDgj0mPOSFCgIKsFdvncHgBoZe3JM4elxLzs58OY= From: cmbecker69@gmx.de ("Christoph M. Becker") On 01.09.2025 at 12:28, Nick wrote: > When I try to look into the discussions of older RFCs to find out why th= ey ended up the way they did, it=E2=80=99s not easy. You hardly can find t= hem. This is because they are often not referenced in the RFC itself. >=20 > Going forward, would it make sense to make it mandatory to reference '[D= iscussion]' and '[Vote]' in the RFC text itself? Well, the RFC template has a "Reference" section which says: | Links to external references, discussions, or RFCs. In my opinion, that is a perfect place to add these links. Of course, someone needs to actually add this information. Christoph