Newsgroups: php.internals
Path: news.php.net
Xref: news.php.net php.internals:126060
Message-ID: <99f8520a-e8ba-471c-bcdb-6f305089c66b@gmx.de>
Date: Tue, 26 Nov 2024 18:16:01 +0100
Precedence: bulk
MIME-Version: 1.0
User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird
Subject: Re: [PHP-DEV] Return When
Content-Language: de-DE
To: Volodymyr Volynets <volodymyr.volynets@gmail.com>, internals@lists.php.net
References: <CAApwWmfN+u4p6WLcy4X=J4vOu5GYiwpqU8sGbg2PF3Bn8oOpHw@mail.gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <CAApwWmfN+u4p6WLcy4X=J4vOu5GYiwpqU8sGbg2PF3Bn8oOpHw@mail.gmail.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:lP03rvt96CM=;SJDB9DNI6IYQW3jDNGPUKvYvhTW
 i23w+ImvU92NZ2NTNvhcCzjMRfM5KeQ5STZ6VhTlch7zUMjvKYOqxl/aiIwalVFqAHBxXQJFk
 vv5XgizWdSih5cfuHFpMvq/H+2tIit2pVD45L+pyChc7sm3L2DALUTJ7E+Yfh8oTLifrvJKmn
 Sdj6KQhcemC+jOc49sWgV0F9jG8a0m7/qa2FURBU4urO8EJVQywiE2ajr7puRAJwl9NEn1/RW
 TGb4tTee1BDrfLqCNgllknahb7N5uwzRLqfaDCGrbbAaxtrVqk3lv0SYbET0se3ls2o9oYEsv
 alHJXOvc2h+Prp3owsjneEa8Q24bhkvZHjrufiLe3RYEro5Oqlw7BGmYBZsi6K3nsWUqy47fb
 JPyZ2vCi+kIjurZViR5hloa8DlmNUQUNdCwzkBNBz2PyD/u7CiTJBqJa93hrslgBBoahhynF9
 aRAOOT1eZgyG1DJJYhaXHSnHvm+gcGo+IvbJXPE1bj+9PJGGby7MkK54+IskEQrNqWJOVAX9V
 j8kyAK8HkexeleqDXIzsdRTG/0KCDT9XcGss4OFr2kofQ7p8q+mNioRDqoz/EZd+ZIS7REEEO
 Z2EzF/zWs02NYIdSVqXiUJ6briSVLzsPDPtERAFxez1N05oW4jyJ5w/bQ2kiGf1sAiGzHb0K9
 Y8qze2mLpXFnGH6Dg53+J3A95FSKBmwTdtUymEQgQEipyiVoMlIcLEVaLzZazHRQPHY7nyI3o
 m9t0i1DrrZk0V7d5KCXWmIuUSwaz3hid6J9O31HnpMxTy8Bkv2I9nGHo0ChRW+rrPNcnqexbn
 Uxz98izouMuix5GTAJO43M0di27PZgB/d0/Qt6Mmzic1XBFZemhULAKwnT4LtbmFwRwETZCY8
 5CiCIS3hfn1ZNESnVCHdoluDTr+4X3mM4PVyE0OKcb0GJpQLNoqL2YT7tnw9aJla6f/Pen9na
 eaDHiQvc1nFrt8tnXu6B7Zy3Dhwo9lqfaZi8rtnXyMKIUMqAQd1k+vVPE+e09G18c/NFm/U2q
 FLtrQBc2m/mSL7tL5Oa+Z8Na2ndH3g5npwGuKlQkRNYAaSxR8eOfk5wfPenAvpSq035fzhrqN
 woYwi79K7Q3d4RJENlsDiDtNC7GHH0
From: cmbecker69@gmx.de ("Christoph M. Becker")

On 26.11.2024 at 17:10, Volodymyr Volynets wrote:

> I have an idea which will save a lot of code. I am proposing to add":
>
> return when [condition], [return value];
>
> This construct will remove a lot of ifs statements after method calls. F=
or
> example:
>
> $result =3D Class->method();
> if (!$result['success']) {
>     return $result;
> }
>
> This becomes:
> return when !$result['success'], $result;
>
> Any thoughts?

What's wrong with

if (!$result['success']) return $result;

That's not longer than what you are proposing, and in my opinion, quite
readable.

The fact that contemporary coding standards require you to write the
if-body on a separate line and to always use braces, is perhaps a
problem of these coding standards.

Christoph